Inside Explorium's Whiskey Library: A Story of Three Bars and One Very Deep Shelf
One friend wants bourbon. One wants a pint of house-made beer. You just want a cozy seat and something worth sipping slowly. At our Third Ward bar in Milwaukee, nobody has to lose that argument. We like to say we pour the largest whiskey selection in the city, and our liquor library backs us up: roughly 460 bottles built around bourbon, rye, and scotch, with plenty beyond. Our Greendale and Wauwatosa bars keep smaller, carefully chosen lineups. Whichever door you walk through, there's a good pour waiting.
How big is the whiskey selection at Explorium Third Ward?
Big enough that people plan a visit around it. The liquor library at our Third Ward home, inside the Pritzlaff Building in the Historic Third Ward, runs across 13 categories: bourbon, rye, scotch, Irish whiskey, Japanese whiskey, other whiskey, tequila, gin, rum, vodka, cordials, cognac and brandy, and a shelf we simply call the Cabinet.
Roughly speaking, that's about 175 bourbons, 95 ryes, 55 scotches, 50 tequilas, 40 Irish whiskeys, 38 gins, 38 cordials, 35 rums, 35 vodkas, 32 other whiskeys, 16 Japanese whiskeys, and 16 cognacs and brandies. Call it roughly 460 bottles on the shelf. We won't pretend we've counted them twice. The wall speaks for itself.
If you've been looking for a whiskey bar in Milwaukee where the list actually goes on, this is the one people mean. Browse the Third Ward liquor library menu before you come, then let our team walk you through the rest in person.
What's in the Cabinet?
The Cabinet is our shelf of rare and collectible pours, about 20 bottles deep. These are the bottles people ask about by name:
Van Winkle 10, 12, and 15 year, plus George T. Stagg and Thomas H. Handy rye
Old Forester Birthday 2022
Balvenie 25 and 30 year, Glenfiddich 30 year, Laphroaig 25 year
Louis XIII cognac and Martell XO
Clase Azul Ultra, Herradura 150th Anniversary, and Cincoro Extra Añejo
Woodford Reserve Baccarat, Código 1530 Playboy II Rare Hare, Heaven's Door Bootleg, Chicken Cock Chanticleer, and Maestro Dobel Silver Oak
Some of these are special-occasion bottles, and availability shifts through the year. If one is calling your name, ask your bartender. That's half the fun of a deep list: somebody behind the bar usually knows where the good stuff is hiding.
What bourbons should you look for?
Bourbon is the heart of the library, with roughly 175 bottles to wander through. A few landmarks:
The full Van Winkle and Weller lines, plus multiple Blanton's expressions
E.H. Taylor, Elmer T. Lee, Eagle Rare, and Stagg Jr.
Booker's, Michter's, Old Fitzgerald, the Penelope lineup, Blue Run, and Bardstown
Our own Explorium picks: Weller Explorium Pick, Woodford Explorium Select, Knob Creek Explorium Single Barrel, and Great Northern Explorium Select Rye
The Explorium picks are barrels we chose ourselves, so they're bottles you can only taste at our bar. If you're the kind of person who keeps a running mental list of bourbons to try, this shelf is where that list gets out of hand. And if you've been hunting for a bourbon bar in Milwaukee with single barrels and house picks, the Third Ward wall is worth the trip downtown.
What if you're more of a rye, scotch, or Japanese whiskey person?
You're covered, too.
Rye: WhistlePig all the way up to Boss Hog, Kentucky Owl 11 year, Michter's 10 year rye, Sagamore finishes, and Chicken Cock Cotton Club.
Scotch: Macallan Rare Cask and Macallan 18 Double Cask, Lagavulin 16, Highland Park 18, Oban 18, Auchentoshan 21, Benriach 20, and Glenmorangie 18.
Japanese: Yamazaki 12 and 18, Hakushu 12, Hibiki Harmony, and Makoto 23 year.
Irish: the Redbreast lineup, Yellow Spot, Green Spot, Writers' Tears, Teeling, and Knappogue up to 16 year.
Not sure where to start? Match the pour to your mood
Love a bold bourbon? Ask for Stagg Jr. or Booker's.
Love a smooth sipper? Try Balvenie or Hibiki Harmony.
Love smoke? Laphroaig or Lagavulin 16.
Love agave? Clase Azul, or just tell your bartender how you take your margarita and go from there.
No tasting vocabulary required. "I like it smooth" and "surprise me" are both perfectly good ways to order.
What about the other locations?
Third Ward is our flagship for whiskey, but it's not the whole story. Greendale, inside Southridge Mall, and Wauwatosa, in the Mayfair Collection, pour smaller but still impressive selections, put together with care rather than sheer size. Think a tight lineup of favorites, chosen by people who taste a lot of whiskey.
Both spots serve the same scratch kitchen and pour from the same 24 rotating taps of house-made beer, with gluten-removed options available. Their menus list house cocktails and a liquor library, with zero-proof options too. If one specific bottle is the whole reason for your visit, call ahead and we'll tell you what's on the shelf that day.

How do you go deeper? Join the Whiskey Club
If one visit turns into a hobby, that's what the Whiskey Club is for. It's our spirits club (whiskey at the heart, but the 2026 program wanders into other pours, too), meeting the first Thursday of every month, with discounted monthly flights, 20% off any whiskey pour and our barrel picks, tastings and events, and pre-order access to sought-after bottles from our barrel picks. Membership is $12 a month, or $10 a month for active Mug Club members — you can join the Whiskey Club here, and if you're already in the Mug Club, use the Mug Club member link for the discounted rate.
Meetings rotate across our locations. On the 2026 calendar so far: a distillery event with Henry & Sons in May, a Willett Distillery event tie-in at Greendale, and a cocktail class at Third Ward in June. Every month is a new corner of the shelf.


Come see the wall
The best way to understand the library is to stand in front of it. Come see the wall at Third Ward, 143 W St. Paul Ave in the Pritzlaff Building, or call 414.423.1365 and we'll save you a seat. You can also reserve a table online. Prefer to scout first? Browse the liquor library menu from your couch.
Closer to the suburbs? Find us in Greendale at 5300 S 76th St, or in Wauwatosa at 11200 W Burleigh St, 414.539.4343. Bar hours are the same everywhere: Sunday 11 a.m. to 9 p.m., Monday through Thursday 11 a.m. to 10 p.m., and Friday and Saturday 11 a.m. to 11 p.m. The kitchen closes an hour earlier.
Bring the beer drinkers, too. With 24 rotating taps of house-made beer, handcrafted cocktails, and scratch-made food, nobody at the table gets left out. Learn more on our Third Ward, Greendale, and Wauwatosa pages, and details on the club are at the Whiskey Club page.
So if you're chasing the best whiskey selection Milwaukee has to offer, start at the Third Ward shelf, and bring a friend who's happy to help you work through it. And if the shelf keeps calling you back, the Whiskey Club is waiting.
Explore. Taste. Discover.

Comments